Two interview questions I hate


Lucas A. Meyer


July 11, 2022

There are two interview questions that I hate, and I see them a lot.

The first is “let’s ask the candidate something ambiguous to see how they deal with ambiguity”. The second is “let’s give them something unsolved to see if we learn something”. A typical version of the latter is using an analytical project as an interview.

When interviewers don’t know the answer

Of these two types of questions, I have a bigger problem with the latter. The worst part is that the problem is unsolved. There’s usually a reason why the problem is still unsolved. The worst type of reason is when the interviewers are incapable of solving the problems themselves. In that case, it’s possible that the candidate will give the right answer and the interviewers won’t recognize it. That’s not very common, but I’ve seen it happen. The candidate is lucky if they don’t get the job.

Some slightly better scenarios are when the interviewer could know the answer, but they don’t because answering that question hasn’t been a priority. In these cases, data is usually bad and/or the question is not well-defined. All those cases are clearly problematic for the candidate to solve under the pressure they face in the interview.


Occasionally, interviewers try to assess a candidate’s ability to “deal with ambiguity” by asking the candidate a question that can’t be answered unless the candidate asks further probing questions. That’s also hard to pull off - the candidate is nervous, and the interviewer has the “curse of knowledge” - questions that are obvious to the interviewer may not be obvious to the candidate.

Even if the interviewer is skilled and experienced enough to pull off something like that, the high-pressure setting of the interview also presents a problem for dealing with ambiguity. Time is ticking. It’s understandable that candidates will sometimes apply for jobs that require solving ambiguous problems under pressure, but those situations are usually different from interviews. When a person gets into a high-pressure situation at work, they usually have a lot of context and at least some preparation. Unless the candidate is aware beforehand that they will get this type of question, this is likely to work out poorly.

It can be done

If they are really necessary, both these types of questions can work out, but they need preparation and experienced interviewers. Sometimes, interviewers create these problems completely unnecessarily, and end up making decisions with bad data.